Past Outstanding Teen Titleholders

2023 – Natalie Popp
2022 – Anna Gruesen
2022 – Keira Dorado (Maritime Bay)
2020/21 – Ellie Krohn
2020/21 – Brooklyn Heyn (Maritime Bay)
2019 – Zoe Rucinsky
2018 – Olivia Lulich
2017 – Grace Stanke
2016 – Sarah Niehueser
2015 – Sophia Pollman
2014 – Sloan Schmitz

2023 – Natalie Popp 
Patriotism Reigns Scholarship

2022 – Keira Dorado (Maritime Bay)

2022 – Anna Gruesen  
Excellence in Athletics Scholarship

2020/2021 – Brooklyn Heyn (Maritime Bay)

2020/2021 – Ellie Krohn

2019 – Zoe Rucinsky
Non-Finalist Fitness Winner

2018 – Olivia Lulich
Non-Finalist Fitness Winner

2017 – Grace Stanke
Miss Wisconsin’s Outstanding Teen 2017
Miss Wisconsin 2022
Miss America 2023

2016 – Sarah Niehueser
Miracle Maker Award Winner
Peers For Peace Essay Award Winner

2015 – Sophia Pollman

2014 – Sloan Schmitz
Miracle Maker Award Winner